Best Used Car Deals in Indiana

We're tracking 215 used listings in Indiana, ranked by the PriceTalon Score (real value — reliability-adjusted life left per dollar). Median price is $25,241, with deals from $5,063. Best value first.

76USED SCORE

$7,000

2012 Volkswagen Jetta Used

50,510 mi · Indianapolis, IN · MarketCheck

⚖

74USED SCORE

$8,244

2016 Mazda Mazda6 Used

146,465 mi · Greenwood, IN · Auto.dev

⚖

72USED SCORE

$18,500

2025 Hyundai Venue Used

29,099 mi · Indianapolis, IN · MarketCheck

⚖

72USED SCORE

$13,974

2017 Mazda Mazda3 Used

80,545 mi · Fishers, IN · MarketCheck

⚖

70USED SCORE

$10,674

2012 Subaru Legacy Used

73,112 mi · Fishers, IN · MarketCheck

⚖

68USED SCORE

$19,694

2024 Hyundai Elantra Used

25,898 mi · Fishers, IN · MarketCheck

⚖

67USED SCORE

$13,774

2014 Subaru Forester Used

62,012 mi · Fishers, IN · MarketCheck

⚖

66USED SCORE

$12,169

2018 Mitsubishi Outlander Sport Used

73,612 mi · Plainfield, IN · MarketCheck

⚖

65USED SCORE

$13,279

2015 Acura Ilx Used

87,944 mi · Indianapolis, IN · MarketCheck

⚖

64USED SCORE

$11,084

2018 Subaru Impreza Used

111,342 mi · Indianapolis, IN · MarketCheck

⚖

64USED SCORE

$14,224

2016 Mazda Cx-5 Used

94,083 mi · Fishers, IN · MarketCheck

⚖

61USED SCORE

$25,207

2023 Honda Civic Used

39,356 mi · Highland, IN · MarketCheck

⚖

60USED SCORE

$25,250

2023 Honda Civic Used

43,859 mi · Highland, IN · MarketCheck

⚖

60USED SCORE

$20,376

2021 Hyundai Elantra Used

38,437 mi · Indianapolis, IN · MarketCheck

⚖

60USED SCORE

$25,689

2025 Subaru Legacy Used

1,832 mi · Indianapolis, IN · MarketCheck

⚖

59USED SCORE

$20,615

2025 Mitsubishi Outlander Sport Used

40,655 mi · Granger, IN · MarketCheck

⚖

58USED SCORE

$18,644

2024 Chevrolet Malibu Used

58,546 mi · Kokomo, IN · Auto.dev

⚖

58USED SCORE

$13,500

2016 Mazda Cx-5 Used

120,224 mi · Indianapolis, IN · MarketCheck

⚖

58USED SCORE

$12,724

2016 Mazda Cx-5 Used

127,880 mi · Fishers, IN · MarketCheck

⚖

57USED SCORE

$14,538

2020 Buick Encore Gx Used

74,280 mi · Indianapolis, IN · Auto.dev

⚖

57USED SCORE

$16,650

2024 Nissan Versa Used

62,540 mi · Highland, IN · MarketCheck

⚖

57USED SCORE

$27,308

2025 Subaru Legacy Used

1,781 mi · Indianapolis, IN · MarketCheck

⚖

57USED SCORE

$23,822

2024 Subaru Crosstrek Used

30,145 mi · Indianapolis, IN · MarketCheck

⚖

56USED SCORE

$26,124

2026 Hyundai Sonata Hybrid Used

10,229 mi · Indianapolis, IN · MarketCheck

⚖

56USED SCORE

$15,500

2020 Buick Encore Used

65,599 mi · Indianapolis, IN · MarketCheck

⚖

55USED SCORE

$29,548

2025 Mazda Cx-5 Used

20,161 mi · Indianapolis, IN · Auto.dev

⚖

55USED SCORE

$25,837

2024 Subaru Crosstrek Used

19,631 mi · Indianapolis, IN · MarketCheck

⚖

55USED SCORE

$18,194

2022 Volkswagen Jetta Used

23,249 mi · Indianapolis, IN · MarketCheck

⚖

55USED SCORE

$27,205

2025 Mazda Cx-5 Used

39,929 mi · Highland, IN · MarketCheck

⚖

54USED SCORE

$12,730

2018 Nissan Armada Used

110,682 mi · Indianapolis, IN · Auto.dev

⚖

54USED SCORE

$27,643

2023 Honda Accord Used

32,060 mi · Highland, IN · MarketCheck

⚖

54USED SCORE

$24,244

2023 Honda Hr-V Used

36,763 mi · Highland, IN · MarketCheck

⚖

54USED SCORE

$29,480

2026 Subaru Crosstrek Used

2,892 mi · Indianapolis, IN · MarketCheck

⚖

54USED SCORE

$28,192

2023 Subaru Forester Used

6,514 mi · Indianapolis, IN · MarketCheck

⚖

54USED SCORE

$26,347

2024 Subaru Crosstrek Used

23,090 mi · Indianapolis, IN · MarketCheck

⚖

54USED SCORE

$25,364

2024 Mazda Mazda3 Used

58,920 mi · Highland, IN · MarketCheck

⚖

← All states