Best Used Car Deals in New York

We're tracking 229 used listings in New York, ranked by the PriceTalon Score (real value — reliability-adjusted life left per dollar). Median price is $25,900, with deals from $4,997. Best value first.

89USED SCORE

$5,995

✅ Good deal

2003 Kia Rio Used

18,856 mi · East Islip, NY · DealerFire

⚖

84USED SCORE

$6,995

✅ Good deal

2006 Hyundai Azera Used

50,000 mi · East Islip, NY · DealerFire

⚖

83USED SCORE

$8,995

✅ Good deal

2009 Honda Fit Used

82,946 mi · East Islip, NY · DealerFire

⚖

82USED SCORE

$9,073

✅ Good deal

2016 Kia Forte Used

79,185 mi · Vestal, NY · DealerFire

⚖

79USED SCORE

$9,900

2019 Hyundai Accent Used

98,826 mi · Richfield Springs, NY · Auto.dev

⚖

71USED SCORE

$13,170

2017 Chevrolet Cruze Used

43,064 mi · Grand Island, NY · Auto.dev

⚖

71USED SCORE

$22,995

2024 Honda Civic Used

20,082 mi · Croton-On-Hudson, NY · Auto.dev

⚖

70USED SCORE 🔻 $8 (0%)

$14,465$14,473

2018 Chevrolet Malibu Used

32,650 mi · Brooklyn, NY · Auto.dev

⚖

69USED SCORE

$7,995

2014 Kia Sorento Used

118,454 mi · East Islip, NY · DealerFire

⚖

66USED SCORE

$17,330

2022 Subaru Brz Used

60,784 mi · Yonkers, NY · Auto.dev

⚖

64USED SCORE

$8,495

2013 Hyundai Sonata Used

106,981 mi · East Islip, NY · DealerFire

⚖

64USED SCORE

$18,170

2014 Honda Accord Used

41,487 mi · Vestal, NY · DealerFire

⚖

64USED SCORE

$8,995

2016 Lincoln Mkc Used

86,061 mi · Ridgewood, NY · MarketCheck

⚖

63USED SCORE

$20,174

2023 Kia Soul Used

45,491 mi · Vestal, NY · DealerFire

⚖

63USED SCORE

$8,998

2015 Kia Optima Used

103,151 mi · Watertown, NY · AutoManager

⚖

63USED SCORE

$17,999

2017 Toyota Rav4 Used

52,243 mi · South Richmond Hill, NY · Auto.dev

⚖

62USED SCORE

$23,910

2025 Hyundai Elantra Used

7,277 mi · Grand Island, NY · MarketCheck

⚖

62USED SCORE

$27,172

2025 Mazda Cx-30 Used

3,527 mi · Cicero, NY · MarketCheck

⚖

62USED SCORE

$6,995

2016 Buick Encore Used

121,517 mi · Ridgewood, NY · MarketCheck

⚖

61USED SCORE

$14,174

2018 Ford Ecosport Used

66,032 mi · Vestal, NY · DealerFire

⚖

61USED SCORE

$14,595

2016 Honda Cr-V Used

91,277 mi · Rochelle, NY · AutoRevo

⚖

61USED SCORE

$27,781

2025 Mazda Cx-30 Used

2,752 mi · Cicero, NY · MarketCheck

⚖

61USED SCORE

$21,590

2025 Mitsubishi Outlander Sport Used

18,942 mi · Latham, NY · MarketCheck

⚖

59USED SCORE

$19,200

2021 Buick Encore Gx Used

22,319 mi · Grand Island, NY · MarketCheck

⚖

59USED SCORE

$10,995

2019 Buick Encore Used

100,267 mi · Ridgewood, NY · MarketCheck

⚖

58USED SCORE

$7,995

2013 Hyundai Sonata Used

122,853 mi · East Islip, NY · DealerFire

⚖

57USED SCORE

$13,173

2018 Dodge Journey Used

68,597 mi · Vestal, NY · DealerFire

⚖

57USED SCORE

$19,500

2021 Tesla Model 3 Used

46,947 mi · Eastchester, NY · Auto.dev

⚖

57USED SCORE

$27,705

2024 Mazda Cx-50 Used

21,402 mi · Cicero, NY · MarketCheck

⚖

57USED SCORE

$26,988

2023 Mazda Cx-30 Used

22,996 mi · Cicero, NY · MarketCheck

⚖

57USED SCORE

$16,995

2022 Mitsubishi Outlander Sport Used

69,855 mi · Ridgewood, NY · MarketCheck

⚖

57USED SCORE

$22,438

2023 Mitsubishi Outlander Used

18,528 mi · Valley Stream, NY · MarketCheck

⚖

56USED SCORE

$12,350

2019 Nissan Sentra Used

73,209 mi · Adams, NY · Auto.dev

⚖

56USED SCORE

$18,626

2019 Honda Cr-V Used

83,081 mi · Plattsburgh, NY · Auto.dev

⚖

56USED SCORE

$27,888

2024 Mazda Cx-5 Used

23,204 mi · Cicero, NY · MarketCheck

⚖

55USED SCORE

$17,996

2017 Subaru Forester Used

72,926 mi · Owego, NY · DealerFire

⚖

← All states