Best Used Subaru Legacy Deals

We're tracking 40 used subaru legacy listings across the country, ranked by the PriceTalon Score (real value — reliability-adjusted life left per dollar). Median price is $15,171, with deals starting around $4,883. The best-value cars are first.

82USED SCORE

$4,995

✅ Good deal

2011 Subaru Legacy Used

119,671 mi · Kenner, LA · AutoRevo

⚖

70USED SCORE

$9,799

2012 Subaru Legacy Used

84,368 mi · Georgetown, MA · MarketCheck

⚖

65USED SCORE

$6,399

2011 Subaru Legacy Used

129,000 mi · Bloomfield, CT · MarketCheck

⚖

64USED SCORE 🔻 $982 (5%)

$18,998$19,980

2023 Subaru Legacy Used

46,715 mi · Bakersfield, CA · Dealer Direct

⚖

63USED SCORE

$12,499

2018 Subaru Legacy Used

97,754 mi · La Crescent, MN · FindCars

⚖

62USED SCORE

$13,792

2017 Subaru Legacy Used

80,105 mi · AutoManager

⚖

61USED SCORE

$11,794

2019 Subaru Legacy Used

115,075 mi · East Windsor, CT · Auto.dev

⚖

61USED SCORE

$24,300

2025 Subaru Legacy Used

9,582 mi · Woods Cross, UT · Auto.dev

⚖

60USED SCORE

$15,998

2015 Subaru Legacy Used

52,800 mi · Gainesville, FL · MarketCheck

⚖

59USED SCORE

$15,171

2017 Subaru Legacy Used

74,588 mi · Vestal, NY · DealerFire

⚖

59USED SCORE

$10,995

2015 Subaru Legacy Used

109,219 mi · Syracuse, NY · MarketCheck

⚖

58USED SCORE

$11,500

2018 Subaru Legacy Used

122,358 mi · Fitchburg, MA · Auto.dev

⚖

58USED SCORE

$4,883

2012 Subaru Legacy Used

159,770 mi · Spartanburg, SC · MarketCheck

⚖

57USED SCORE

$26,390

2025 Subaru Legacy Used

8,936 mi · Mount Joy, PA · DealerFire

⚖

57USED SCORE

$25,487

2024 Subaru Legacy Used

12,860 mi · Hollidaysburg, PA · MarketCheck

⚖

56USED SCORE

$6,999

2015 Subaru Legacy Used

155,793 mi · Pueblo, CO · Auto.dev

⚖

55USED SCORE

$27,326

2025 Subaru Legacy Used

11,805 mi · Bensenville, IL · MarketCheck

⚖

55USED SCORE

$27,326

2025 Subaru Legacy Used

10,244 mi · Bensenville, IL · MarketCheck

⚖

55USED SCORE

$27,326

2025 Subaru Legacy Used

13,339 mi · Bensenville, IL · MarketCheck

⚖

54USED SCORE

$18,924

2023 Subaru Legacy Used

87,949 mi · Mcminnville, OR · MarketCheck

⚖

54USED SCORE

$27,326

2025 Subaru Legacy Used

16,642 mi · Bensenville, IL · MarketCheck

⚖

54USED SCORE

$27,326

2025 Subaru Legacy Used

16,382 mi · Bensenville, IL · MarketCheck

⚖

53USED SCORE

$15,594

2021 Subaru Legacy Used

111,980 mi · Wichita, KS · Auto.dev

⚖

53USED SCORE

$6,995

2005 Subaru Legacy Used

110,689 mi · Hope Mills, NC · AutoRevo

⚖

53USED SCORE

$14,933

2018 Subaru Legacy Used

101,628 mi · Rochester, MN · FindCars

⚖

53USED SCORE

$22,590

2022 Subaru Legacy Used

53,192 mi · Akron, NY · MarketCheck

⚖

53USED SCORE

$26,500

2025 Subaru Legacy Used

32,012 mi · Clintwood, VA · MarketCheck

⚖

51USED SCORE

$19,995

2024 Subaru Legacy Used

94,963 mi · Houston, TX · DealerFire

⚖

51USED SCORE 🔻 $300 (2%)

$19,195$19,495

2021 Subaru Legacy Used

86,678 mi · Rochester, MN · FindCars

⚖

50USED SCORE

$31,599

2025 Subaru Legacy Used

4,237 mi · O'fallon, MO · Auto.dev

⚖

45USED SCORE

$23,894

2025 Subaru Legacy Used

97,195 mi · Greensboro, NC · MarketCheck

⚖

44USED SCORE

$9,995

2005 Subaru Legacy Used

101,290 mi · Alamosa, CO · MarketCheck

⚖

44USED SCORE

$34,608

2024 Subaru Legacy Used

16,846 mi · Folsom, CA · MarketCheck

⚖

42USED SCORE

$14,347

2016 Subaru Legacy Used

132,006 mi · Bloomington, MN · MarketCheck

⚖

39USED SCORE

$10,988

2015 Subaru Legacy Used

155,839 mi · AutoManager

⚖

35USED SCORE

$8,350

2015 Subaru Legacy Used

179,620 mi · La Crosse, WI · FindCars

⚖

📈 See Subaru Legacy price trends →

← All car deals by make