Used Subaru Legacy Prices & Best Deals

We're tracking 143 used subaru legacy listings across the country, ranked by the PriceTalon Score (real value — reliability-adjusted life left per dollar). Median price is $17,484, with deals starting around $3,495. The best-value cars are first.

91USED SCORE

$5,500

🔥 Insane deal

2013 Subaru Legacy Used

70,272 mi · Stoystown, PA · ComSoft

⚖

90USED SCORE

$5,900

🔥 Insane deal

2017 Subaru Legacy Used

88,108 mi · Stoystown, PA · ComSoft

⚖

85USED SCORE

$3,990

✅ Good deal

2008 Subaru Legacy Used

111,630 mi · Tampa, FL · Wayne Reaves

⚖

80USED SCORE

$8,818

✅ Good deal

2011 Subaru Legacy Used

69,980 mi · Jonestown, PA · Auto.dev

⚖

79USED SCORE

$9,995

2014 Subaru Legacy Used

72,297 mi · AutoManager

⚖

74USED SCORE

$11,989

2015 Subaru Legacy Used

61,553 mi · Salt Lake City, UT · Overfuel

⚖

74USED SCORE

$9,990

2013 Subaru Legacy Used

77,575 mi · Selden, NY · Overfuel

⚖

74USED SCORE

$5,997

2005 Subaru Legacy Used

92,142 mi · Shawnee, KS · MarketCheck

⚖

73USED SCORE

$6,550

2012 Subaru Legacy Used

120,965 mi · Winchester, VA · Auto.dev

⚖

73USED SCORE 🔻 $499 (3%)

$15,995$16,494

2023 Subaru Legacy Used

47,969 mi · West Jordan, UT · Overfuel

⚖

71USED SCORE 🔻 $112 (1%)

$9,688$9,800

2013 Subaru Legacy Used

88,037 mi · Pasco, WA · ProMax

⚖

71USED SCORE

$7,999

2014 Subaru Legacy Used

116,297 mi · Santa Cruz, CA · AutoManager

⚖

69USED SCORE 🔻 $100 (0%)

$21,195$21,295

2025 Subaru Legacy Used

8,785 mi · Jacksonville, FL · Overfuel

⚖

69USED SCORE

$20,950

2025 Subaru Legacy Used

11,039 mi · Columbus, OH · Overfuel

⚖

67USED SCORE

$8,995

2016 Subaru Legacy Used

119,808 mi · Peachtree Corners, GA · Wayne Reaves

⚖

67USED SCORE 🔻 $500 (5%)

$10,500$11,000

2014 Subaru Legacy Used

91,510 mi · Norwalk, CT · Remora

⚖

66USED SCORE

$10,995

2015 Subaru Legacy Used

93,909 mi · Louisville, TN · Auto.dev

⚖

66USED SCORE

$13,393

2015 Subaru Legacy Used

64,884 mi · Lancaster, OH · Overfuel

⚖

65USED SCORE

$22,989

2025 Subaru Legacy Used

3,819 mi · Salt Lake City, UT · Overfuel

⚖

64USED SCORE 🔻 $413 (2%)

$21,385$21,798

2023 Subaru Legacy Used

18,744 mi · Frederick, MD · Overfuel

⚖

64USED SCORE

$20,466

2024 Subaru Legacy Used

33,852 mi · Kaysville, UT · Overfuel

⚖

63USED SCORE

$8,995

2017 Subaru Legacy Used

132,839 mi · Carlstadt, NJ · Overfuel

⚖

63USED SCORE

$15,689

2017 Subaru Legacy Used

57,094 mi · Littleton, CO · Overfuel

⚖

63USED SCORE

$6,700

2011 Subaru Legacy Used

129,314 mi · Johnson City, TN · Wayne Reaves

⚖

62USED SCORE

$12,990

2015 Subaru Legacy Used

80,868 mi · Harrisburg, PA · MarketCheck

⚖

62USED SCORE 🔻 $600 (7%)

$7,500$8,100

2015 Subaru Legacy Used

140,750 mi · Columbus, OH · Overfuel

⚖

61USED SCORE

$21,749

2025 Subaru Legacy Used

35,818 mi · Mount Vernon, WA · Auto.dev

⚖

61USED SCORE 🔻 $744 (4%)

$16,827$17,571

2020 Subaru Legacy Used

64,846 mi · Chantilly, VA · Overfuel

⚖

61USED SCORE

$19,471

2022 Subaru Legacy Used

45,887 mi · Kaysville, UT · Overfuel

⚖

61USED SCORE 🔻 $500 (7%)

$6,995$7,495

2013 Subaru Legacy Used

138,537 mi · San Jose, CA · AutoManager

⚖

61USED SCORE

$15,987

2015 Subaru Legacy Used

48,629 mi · Rochester, MN · FindCars

⚖

60USED SCORE

$7,000

2014 Subaru Legacy Used

145,193 mi · AutoManager

⚖

60USED SCORE

$24,998

2025 Subaru Legacy Used

9,404 mi · Akron, OH · Remora

⚖

60USED SCORE 🔻 $1,000 (4%)

$22,599$23,599

2023 Subaru Legacy Used

23,073 mi · Meriden, CT · Overfuel

⚖

60USED SCORE 🔻 $90 (0%)

$18,498$18,588

2024 Subaru Legacy Used

70,264 mi · Jacksonville, FL · Overfuel

⚖

59USED SCORE

$23,763

2025 Subaru Legacy Used

26,188 mi · Arlington, TX · Dealer Direct

⚖

📈 See Subaru Legacy price trends →

← All car deals by make