🦅 PriceTalon
⚠️ Verify before you buy. Accident & title history isn't available from our data sources. Always review each listing and run the VIN to confirm the vehicle meets your expectations.

Best Used Tesla Model Y Deals

We're tracking 119 used tesla model y listings across the country, ranked by the PriceTalon Score (real value — reliability-adjusted life left per dollar). Median price is $33,300, with deals starting around $20,995. The best-value cars are first.

Get free deal alerts for Used Tesla Model Y → Free · we email you when a great used tesla model y deal hits the market.
2020 Tesla Model Y
46USED SCORE
$24,600
2020 Tesla Model Y Used
48,615 mi · Carrollton, TX · AutoRevo
2022 Tesla Model Y
46USED SCORE
$27,800
2022 Tesla Model Y Used
37,305 mi · Carrollton, TX · AutoRevo
2022 Tesla Model Y
46USED SCORE
$27,300
2022 Tesla Model Y Used
37,688 mi · Carrollton, TX · AutoRevo
2020 Tesla Model Y
45USED SCORE
$24,800
2020 Tesla Model Y Used
52,413 mi · Carrollton, TX · AutoRevo
2023 Tesla Model Y
44USED SCORE
$26,100
2023 Tesla Model Y Used
66,696 mi · Carrollton, TX · AutoRevo
2021 Tesla Model Y
44USED SCORE
$26,814
2021 Tesla Model Y Used
50,925 mi · Champaign, IL · Auto.dev
2022 Tesla Model Y
43USED SCORE
$33,225
2022 Tesla Model Y Used
17,050 mi · Carrollton, TX · AutoRevo
2024 Tesla Model Y
43USED SCORE
$34,200
2024 Tesla Model Y Used
16,947 mi · Carrollton, TX · AutoRevo
2024 Tesla Model Y
43USED SCORE
$33,950
2024 Tesla Model Y Used
16,520 mi · Carrollton, TX · AutoRevo
2022 Tesla Model Y
43USED SCORE
$29,021
2022 Tesla Model Y Used
43,679 mi · Charleston, SC · MarketCheck
2023 Tesla Model Y
42USED SCORE
$33,488
2023 Tesla Model Y Used
25,960 mi · Sarasota, FL · DealerFire
2021 Tesla Model Y
42USED SCORE
$30,632
2021 Tesla Model Y Used
32,346 mi · Carrollton, TX · AutoRevo
2020 Tesla Model Y
42USED SCORE
$27,481
2020 Tesla Model Y Used
53,016 mi · Greensboro, NC · MarketCheck
2020 Tesla Model Y
42USED SCORE
$27,000
2020 Tesla Model Y Used
55,971 mi · Raleigh, NC · MarketCheck
2021 Tesla Model Y
42USED SCORE
$26,499
2021 Tesla Model Y Used
64,614 mi · Ottawa, KS · MarketCheck
2021 Tesla Model Y
42USED SCORE
$29,313
2021 Tesla Model Y Used
43,748 mi · East Hartford, CT · MarketCheck
2021 Tesla Model Y
42USED SCORE
$27,493
2021 Tesla Model Y Used
58,377 mi · Sussex, NJ · MarketCheck
2021 Tesla Model Y
42USED SCORE
$26,995
2021 Tesla Model Y Used
57,350 mi · Fairborn, OH · MarketCheck
2022 Tesla Model Y
42USED SCORE
$32,526
2022 Tesla Model Y Used
27,194 mi · West Valley City, UT · MarketCheck
2023 Tesla Model Y
42USED SCORE
$28,812
2023 Tesla Model Y Used
56,758 mi · North Aurora, IL · MarketCheck
2021 Tesla Model Y
41USED SCORE
$27,985
2021 Tesla Model Y Used
59,801 mi · Carrollton, TX · AutoRevo
2023 Tesla Model Y
41USED SCORE
$32,190
2023 Tesla Model Y Used
44,475 mi · Hills, CA · Dealer Direct
2021 Tesla Model Y
41USED SCORE
$26,855
2021 Tesla Model Y Used
65,751 mi · Mountain View, CA · MarketCheck
2021 Tesla Model Y
41USED SCORE
$28,720
2021 Tesla Model Y Used
53,055 mi · Sanford, FL · MarketCheck
2022 Tesla Model Y
41USED SCORE
$33,771
2022 Tesla Model Y Used
25,635 mi · Raleigh, NC · MarketCheck
2023 Tesla Model Y
41USED SCORE
$31,599
2023 Tesla Model Y Used
47,006 mi · Snellville, GA · MarketCheck
2023 Tesla Model Y
41USED SCORE
$35,500
2023 Tesla Model Y Used
21,180 mi · Raleigh, NC · MarketCheck
2023 Tesla Model Y
41USED SCORE
$36,600
2023 Tesla Model Y Used
11,479 mi · Greensboro, NC · MarketCheck
2023 Tesla Model Y
41USED SCORE
$34,700
2023 Tesla Model Y Used
20,987 mi · Raleigh, NC · MarketCheck
2024 Tesla Model Y
41USED SCORE
$33,592
2024 Tesla Model Y Used
39,954 mi · Loveland, CO · MarketCheck
2025 Tesla Model Y
40USED SCORE
$40,950
2025 Tesla Model Y Used
3,814 mi · Las Vegas, NV · DealerFire
2020 Tesla Model Y
40USED SCORE
$29,912
2020 Tesla Model Y Used
45,695 mi · Carrollton, TX · AutoRevo
2021 Tesla Model Y
40USED SCORE
$28,348
2021 Tesla Model Y Used
60,970 mi · Tampa, FL · Dealer Direct
2022 Tesla Model Y
40USED SCORE 🔻 $1,063 (3%)
$35,419$36,482
2022 Tesla Model Y Used
25,763 mi · Austin, TX · Dealer Direct
2021 Tesla Model Y
40USED SCORE
$30,494
2021 Tesla Model Y Used
50,460 mi · Henderson, NV · MarketCheck
2021 Tesla Model Y
40USED SCORE
$30,100
2021 Tesla Model Y Used
54,364 mi · Raleigh, NC · MarketCheck

📈 See Tesla Model Y price trends →

← All car deals by make