Used Tesla Model Y Prices & Best Deals

We're tracking 420 used tesla model y listings across the country, ranked by the PriceTalon Score (real value — reliability-adjusted life left per dollar). Median price is $33,200, with deals starting around $14,995. The best-value cars are first.

54USED SCORE

$26,999

2025 Tesla Model Y Used

9,000 mi · Miami, FL · Auto.dev

⚖

53USED SCORE 🔻 $499 (2%)

$24,995$25,494

2023 Tesla Model Y Used

22,124 mi · West Jordan, UT · Overfuel

⚖

50USED SCORE 🔻 $1,000 (4%)

$26,494$27,494

2022 Tesla Model Y Used

20,148 mi · Salt Lake City, UT · Overfuel

⚖

49USED SCORE

$22,290

2021 Tesla Model Y Used

59,931 mi · Portland, OR · Auto.dev

⚖

49USED SCORE

$24,195

2022 Tesla Model Y Used

49,854 mi · Portland, OR · Auto.dev

⚖

49USED SCORE

$27,995

2024 Tesla Model Y Used

28,511 mi · Millcreek, UT · Motorlot

⚖

49USED SCORE 🔻 $1,000 (4%)

$27,494$28,494

2023 Tesla Model Y Used

22,696 mi · Salt Lake City, UT · Overfuel

⚖

48USED SCORE 🔻 $9,381 (30%)

$21,995$31,376

2020 Tesla Model Y Used

60,114 mi · Honolulu, HI · Overfuel

⚖

48USED SCORE

$28,995

2024 Tesla Model Y Used

22,900 mi · Millcreek, UT · Motorlot

⚖

48USED SCORE 🔻 $500 (2%)

$28,989$29,489

2023 Tesla Model Y Used

18,917 mi · Salt Lake City, UT · Overfuel

⚖

48USED SCORE 🔻 $1,000 (3%)

$29,489$30,489

2024 Tesla Model Y Used

19,612 mi · Salt Lake City, UT · Overfuel

⚖

48USED SCORE 🔻 $280 (1%)

$30,470$30,750

2025 Tesla Model Y Used

16,416 mi · Lindon, UT · Overfuel

⚖

47USED SCORE

$26,239

2022 Tesla Model Y Used

43,076 mi · Salt Lake City, UT · Overfuel

⚖

47USED SCORE

$30,995

2025 Tesla Model Y Used

16,447 mi · Millcreek, UT · Motorlot

⚖

47USED SCORE

$30,489

2024 Tesla Model Y Used

17,713 mi · Salt Lake City, UT · Overfuel

⚖

47USED SCORE 🔻 $100 (0%)

$27,731$27,831

2024 Tesla Model Y Used

39,954 mi · Salt Lake City, UT · Overfuel

⚖

46USED SCORE

$26,200

2020 Tesla Model Y Used

38,148 mi · Boise, ID · Auto.dev

⚖

46USED SCORE

$29,300

2024 Tesla Model Y Used

34,000 mi · Flint, MI · Auto.dev

⚖

46USED SCORE

$33,070

2025 Tesla Model Y Used

13,265 mi · Fort Edward, NY · Auto.dev

⚖

46USED SCORE

$28,489

2023 Tesla Model Y Used

34,816 mi · Salt Lake City, UT · Overfuel

⚖

46USED SCORE

$29,995

2025 Tesla Model Y Used

34,736 mi · Millcreek, UT · Motorlot

⚖

45USED SCORE

$25,950

2020 Tesla Model Y Used

45,513 mi · Columbus, OH · Overfuel

⚖

45USED SCORE

$26,762

2021 Tesla Model Y Used

44,038 mi · Fishers, IN · Overfuel

⚖

45USED SCORE

$28,989

2023 Tesla Model Y Used

36,066 mi · Salt Lake City, UT · Overfuel

⚖

45USED SCORE

$30,489

2024 Tesla Model Y Used

33,006 mi · Salt Lake City, UT · Overfuel

⚖

44USED SCORE

$27,600

2022 Tesla Model Y Used

48,770 mi · Clearwater, FL · Auto.dev

⚖

44USED SCORE

$26,946

2023 Tesla Model Y Used

59,940 mi · Victoria, TX · Auto.dev

⚖

44USED SCORE

$28,489

2024 Tesla Model Y Used

52,677 mi · Salt Lake City, UT · Overfuel

⚖

44USED SCORE

$21,331

2021 Tesla Model Y Used

89,810 mi · Salt Lake City, UT · Overfuel

⚖

44USED SCORE 🔻 $124 (0%)

$27,441$27,565

2023 Tesla Model Y Used

53,352 mi · Salt Lake City, UT · Overfuel

⚖

44USED SCORE 🔻 $700 (2%)

$27,995$28,695

2021 Tesla Model Y Used

42,341 mi · Honolulu, HI · Overfuel

⚖

44USED SCORE

$24,545

2021 Tesla Model Y Used

65,997 mi · Columbus, OH · Overfuel

⚖

44USED SCORE 🔻 $300 (1%)

$24,890$25,190

2021 Tesla Model Y Used

65,685 mi · Great Neck, NY · Overfuel

⚖

44USED SCORE 🔻 $1,900 (7%)

$23,890$25,790

2023 Tesla Model Y Used

83,415 mi · Great Neck, NY · Overfuel

⚖

43USED SCORE

$27,874

2020 Tesla Model Y Used

41,417 mi · Orlando, FL · Auto.dev

⚖

43USED SCORE

$24,022

2021 Tesla Model Y Used

75,955 mi · Anaheim, CA · Auto.dev

⚖

📈 See Tesla Model Y price trends →

← All car deals by make